Kathryn Ivy

Silky Merino

Reviewed by Alice Schnebly

Malabrigo Silky Merino in color #416, Indiecita

Manufacturer: Malabrigo Yarns
Fiber content: 50% Silk, 50% Baby Merino Wool
Gauge: 4.5 sts = 1" on US 8 needles or 5.25 sts = 1" on US 7 needles, DK weight
Weight/yardage per skein: 50 grams/150 yards (137 meters)
Average retail price: $9.50/skein
Manufacturer’s care instructions: Hand wash, dry flat
Color used: #416, Indiecita
Date Reviewed: 3/13/2008

First Look

Silky Merino skeinedThere is no doubt that Malabrigo's new Silky Merino line is absolutely stunning. Right away I was taken by how gorgeous the yarn was, even in skein form. The colors are perfect and the silky sheen really adds depth to them. The skeins are very soft and squishy. Even before knitting though, I could tell that each skein was not consistent in its coloring.

Knitting it Up

While winding my first skein, I was extremely happy to find that there were no knots. Overall, I went through 5 skeins of yarn, and found not a single knot. This seems to be a rarity in the yarn business. In yarns like Noro Silk Garden or Debbie Bliss Cashmerino Aran I've found up to five knots per skein. Even three knots (which I've been told is the industry's acceptable number per skein) is a bit excessive. I am glad Malabrigo holds its yarns to a higher standard, as I've never found a knot in their Merino Worsted line either.

Silky Merino skeinedSilky Merino stays a consistent thickness throughout. While knitting it felt between a DK/ and light worsted weight, and could be used for projects that call for either. A great thing about this yarn is that it would be suitable for a wide variety of projects, depending on the gauge you knit it at. I knit Silky Merino at a gauge of 4.5sts/inch for my Step Ribbed Stole (on size US9 needles) and the fabric is perfectly drapey. The fabric is slightly open, so I wouldn't suggest knitting at this gauge for a garment but it looks great in something like a shawl or a scarf. I also knit up swatches at two other gauges. My swatch on US8s was still fairly open and grew from 5sts/inch to 4.5 sts/inch after washing. I really loved how the yarn knit up on US7's. Before washing, I got 5.75sts/inch and after 5.25sts/inch. I love the look of the small, uniform stitches. The yarn plumped up a bit after washing and created an even and solid fabric. The swatch stayed more true to shape than at the larger gauge. This yarn knit up at a gauge between 5-5.5 sts/inch would probably be suitable for use in a garment, though not as much drape is present at this smaller gauge.

It's a Wash

Silky Merino is a hand wash only yarn. Some people may find this annoying, but once you work with this yarn you will want to take special care to keep your knitted item looking wonderful. I washed both my swatches in tepid water using Kookaburra Delicate wool wash. I used light agitation, and then let my items soak for thirty minutes. No dye bled from the yarn at all. After I removed the excess water, I laid my items out flat to dry. The stitches relaxed significantly. My swatch knit at the smaller gauge held its shape noticeably better than the larger gauge swatch. It also has more memory and more resilience after stretching.

Pros

Cons

  • Coloways can vary dramatically from skein to skein
  • Hand Wash only

Conclusions

Step Ribbed Stole in Silky MerinoI think this blend of silk and wool is absolutely perfect. I can see characteristics of both present in this yarn. I love the sheen and drape provided by the silk, and the softness is divine. I also love that the wool adds real body to the yarn. It feels sturdy and substantial while knitting. The presence of wool adds a bit of memory that isn't there with just silk. I feel that the wool also gave my stitches a pretty and even appearance and creates a loft that makes the stitches even out and plump up after washing. This yarn is easy to spit splice together as well, which is a big plus in a large project. I could see using this yarn over and over. It's the perfect combination of luxury and durability.

The only downside I can find in this yarn, is that the colorways aren't consistent from skein to skein. This doesn't cause a problem when working on a smaller project, but if purchasing yarn for a larger item it's something to keep in mind. If you have a chance to see the yarn in person before buying, you can try to match your skeins as much as possible. Also, if ordering online, it doesn't hurt to ask the shop to send you similarly colored skeins. Most places will be accommodating and helpful.


 

Comments

  • April 9, 2010, 1:33 am - Naomi (www.benderoak.com)

    Hi! I saw that you mentioned you did a review of this yarn on a Ravelry forum. I wanted to know if you could provide some insight? Would you consider Silky Merino as soft as or softer than Malabrigo Worsted? I don't have any stores nearby that carry Silky Merino, and I'd like to purchase a sweater quantity, though I do see that there's some color inconsistencies, as you have mentioned! any response would be appreciated (here or email), I want to treat myself to a nice order of Malabrigo, but I want to make the right decision.

  • May 11, 2008, 9:01 am - taj

    can malabrigo's silky merino be compared to lorna laces lion&lamb(wool+silk-50%)or with cherry tree hills silk merino that too has wool+silk 50% of each.have you knitted with the other two yarns ?? lion&lamb and CT hills meriono silk are both highly priced.besides the price factor is malabrigos silky merino equaaly good in quality too. kindly reply .thanks.

  • March 28, 2008, 11:33 am - bree

    Awesome site and review! And I have to agree with Jennifer that all of your projects are perfection!

    Manos silk blend has less silk. It's still nice though- I'm making the clapotis with it right now.

  • March 14, 2008, 11:17 am - Jennifer (nuttyirishmanknits.typepad.com)

    Alice, your knowledge scares me. But I think I now understand why your knits finish up spot on, every time. (Emphasis on every.) This yarn looks divine. And I'm sad to hear someone other than me has issues with Manos and Debbie Bliss when it comes to knots. I thought I just had horrible luck in picking skeins!

  • March 13, 2008, 7:23 pm - kelp! (http://www.kelpknits.com)

    Nice review! I need to get my rear in gear and check this stuff out at my lys. I wonder how it compares to the new Manos silk blend?


Add Your Comment

Your Name*:
Email:
Website:
Address:
Comment*: